2016
| Rank | School |
| 1. | Cathedral |
| 2. | Carmel |
| 3. | North Central |
| 4. | S.B. St. Joe |
| 5. | Jasper |
| 6. | Terre Haute South |
| 7. | Center Grove |
| 8. | Penn |
| 9. | Delta |
| 10. | FW Carroll |
| 11. | Park Tudor |
| 12. | Brownsburg |
| 13. | Avon |
| 14. | Fairfield |
| 15. | Munster |
| 16. | Elkhart Memorial |
| 17. | Marion |
| 18. | Zionsville |
| 19. | Columbus North |
| 20. | Bloomington North |
| 21. | Evansville Mater Dei |
| 22. | Gibson Southern |
| 23. | FW Canterbury |
| 24. | HSE |
| 25. | Providence |
| 26. | Guerin Catholic |
| 27. | Adams Central |
| 28. | Terre Haute North |
| 29. | Castle |
| 30. (tie) | West Lafayette |
| 30. (tie) | Warsaw |
2015
| Rank | School |
| 1. | Carmel |
| 2. | Cathedral |
| 3. | North Central |
| 4. | S.B. St. Joseph |
| 5. | Penn |
| 6. | Jasper |
| 7. | Fairfield |
| 8. | Delta |
| 9. | Munster |
| 10. | Avon |
| 11. | Guerin Catholic |
| 12. | Park Tudor |
| 13. | FW Canterbury |
| 14. | Bloomington South |
| 15. | Terre Haute South |
| 16. | Center Grove |
| 17. | Evansville Memorial |
| 18. | Bloomington North |
| 19. | Marion |
| 20. | FW Carroll |
| 21. | Columbus North |
| 22. | Castle |
| 23. | HSE |
| 24. | Seymour |
| 25. | Elkhart Memorial |
| 26. | Concord |
| 27. | Terre Haute North |
| 28. | Fishers |
| 29. | Plymouth |
| 30. | Brebeuf |
2014
| Rank | School |
| 1. | Carmel |
| 2. | North Central |
| 3. | Evansville Memorial |
| 4. | Cathedral |
| 5. | Park Tudor |
| 6. | Greenwood |
| 7. | Bloomington North |
| 8. | Guerin Catholic |
| 9. | Floyd Central |
| 10. | FW Canterbury |
| 11. | Jasper |
| 12. | Terre Haute North |
| 13. | Bloomington South |
| 14. | Penn |
| 15. | SB St. Joseph |
| 16. | Elkhart Memorial |
| 17. | Culver Academy |
| 18. | Columbus North |
| 19. | Crown Point |
| 20. | Marion |
| 21. | FW Carroll |
| 22. | Munster |
| 23. | Zionsville |
| 24. | Delta |
| 25. | HSE |
| 26. | Lafayette Harrison |
| 27. | Terre Haute South |
| 28. | Center Grove |
| 29. | Mississinewa |
| 30. | Seymour |
2013
| Rank | School |
| 1. | Carmel |
| 2. | Evansville Memorial |
| 3. | Floyd Central |
| 4. | Penn |
| 5. | Jasper |
| 6. | North Central |
| 7. | Cathedral |
| 8. | Park Tudor |
| 9. | Fisher |
| 10. | Brebeuf |
| 11. | Delta |
| 12. | FW Carroll |
| 13. | Greenwood |
| 14. | Bloomington North |
| 15. | Bloomington South |
| 16. | Munster |
| 17. | HSE |
| 18. | Valparaiso |
| 19. | SB St. Joseph |
| 20. | Castle |
| 21. | Guerin Catholic |
| 22. | Chesterton |
| 23. | Zionsville |
| 24. | Center Grove |
| 25. | Northridge |
| 26. | Marion |
| 27. | Homestead |
| 28. | Franklin |
| 29. | Roncalli |
| 30. (tie) | TH South |
| 30. (tie) | Northeastern |
2012
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Evansville Memorial |
| 2 | Carmel |
| 3 | Floyd Central |
| 4 | Penn |
| 5 | Cathedral |
| 6 | Jasper |
| 7 | Munster |
| 8 | Fishers |
| 9 | Highland |
| 10 | Chesterton |
| 11 | SB St. Joseph's |
| 12 | FW Canterbury |
| 13 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 14 | Columbus North |
| 15 | Bloomington South |
| 16 | Greenwood |
| 17 | Bloomington North |
| 18 | Zionsville |
| 19 | Roncalli |
| 20 | Brebeuf |
| 21 | Park Tudor |
| 22 | Delta |
| 23 | Valparaiso |
| 24 | FW Concordia |
| 25 | Center Grove |
| 26 | Franklin |
| 27 | Bishop Chatard |
| 28 | Castle |
| 29 | TH South |
| 30 | (tie). FW Carroll |
| (tie). Silver Creek |
2011
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Carmel |
| 2 | Evansville Memorial |
| 3 | South Bend St Joseph's |
| 4 | Floyd Central |
| 5 | Jasper |
| 6 | North Central |
| 7 | Penn |
| 8 | Columbus North |
| 9 | Cathedral |
| 10 | Highland |
| 11 | Brebeuf |
| 12 | Munster |
| 13 | FW Bishop Dwenger |
| 14 | Bloomington North |
| 15 | Terre Haute North |
| 16 | Homestead |
| 17 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 18 | Zionsville |
| 19 | Center Grove |
| 20 | Fishers |
| 21 | Noblesville |
| 22 | Plainfield |
| 23 | Delta |
| 24 | Roncalli |
| 25 | West Lafayette |
| 26 | FW Carroll |
| 27 | Fairfield |
| 28 | Park Tudor |
| 29 | FW Canterbury |
| 30 | (Tie). Valparaiso |
| (Tie). Bishop Chatard |
2010
| Rank | School |
| 1 | SB St Joseph's |
| 2 | Columbus North |
| 3 | Carmel |
| 4 | Cathedral |
| 5 | Park Tudor |
| 6 | TH South |
| 7 | Highland |
| 8 | Evansville Memorial |
| 9 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 10 | Center Grove |
| 11 | Floyd Central |
| 12 | Munster |
| 13 | Penn |
| 14 | Chesterton |
| 15 | Jasper |
| 16 | TH North |
| 17 | Brebeuf |
| 18 | Zionsville |
| 19 | Homestead |
| 20 | Greenwood |
| 21 | FW Canterbury |
| 22 | Brownsburg |
| 23 | Yorktown |
| 24 | Bishop Chatard |
| 25 | Roncalli |
| 26 | Plainfield |
| 27 | Noblesville |
| 28 | Fairfield |
| 29 | Marion |
| 30 | (tie) Northridge |
| (tie). Bishop Chatard |
2009
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Park Tudor |
| 2 | Munster |
| 3 | Carmel |
| 4 | Cathedral |
| 5 | Jasper |
| 6 | Center Grove |
| 7 | Terre Haute South |
| 8 | Terre Haute North |
| 9 | Columbus North |
| 10 | Greenwood |
| 11 | Brebeuf |
| 12 | SB St. Joseph's |
| 13 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 14 | Homestead |
| 15 | Zionsville |
| 16 | FW Canterbury |
| 17 | Penn |
| 18 | Valparaiso |
| 19 | Highland |
| 20 | Evansville Memorial |
| 21 | Roncalli |
| 22 | Delta |
| 23 | Anderson Highland |
| 24 | Floyd Central |
| 25 | Noblesville |
| 26 | Bishop Chatard |
| 27 | Marion |
| 28 | Kankakee Valley |
| 29 | Martinsville |
| 30 | (tie). Culver Academy |
| (tie). Bishop Chatard |
2008
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Park Tudor |
| 2 | (tie). Munster |
| 3 | (tie). Carmel |
| 4 | Zionsville |
| 5 | Jasper |
| 6 | Cathedral |
| 7 | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 8 | Terre Haute South |
| 9 | Center Grove |
| 10 | (tie). Columbus North |
| 11 | (tie). Michigan City |
| 12 | Terre Haute North |
| 13 | Fort Wayne Canterbury |
| 14 | Anderson Highland |
| 15 | North Central |
| 16 | Franklin |
| 17 | South Bend St. Joseph's |
| 18 | Penn |
| 19 | Culver Academies |
| 20 | Greenwood |
| 21 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 22 | Homestead |
| 23 | Noblesville |
| 24 | West Lafayette |
| 25 | Lafayette Harrison |
| 26 | Evansville Memorial |
| 27 | Northridge |
| 28 | Silver Creek |
| 29 | Marion |
| 30 | Highland |
2007
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Park Tudor |
| 2 | Munster |
| 3 | Jasper |
| 4 | Carmel |
| 5 | Homestead |
| 6 | Bloomington South |
| 7 | FW Canterbury |
| 8 | Center Grove |
| 9 | Zionsville |
| 10 | Cathedral |
| 11 | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 12 | Delta |
| 13 | Columbus North |
| 14 | North Central |
| 15 | Terre Haute South |
| 16 | Greenwood |
| 17 | Bishop Chatard |
| 18 | Michigan City |
| 19 | Culver Academies |
| 20 | Bedford North Lawrence |
2006
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Park Tudor |
| 2 | Munster |
| 3 | Center Grove |
| 4 | Carmel |
| 5 | Homestead |
| 6 | Delta |
| 7 | Terre Haute North |
| 8 | North Central |
| 9 | Bloomington South |
| 10 | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 11 | Jasper |
| 12 | Cathedral |
| 13 | Zionsville |
| 14 | Franklin Central |
| 15 | Hamilton Southeastern |
| 16 | Avon |
| 17 | Brownsburg |
| 18 | Elkhart Central |
| 19 | Terre Haute South |
| 20 | (tie) Plymouth |
| (tie) Bishop Chatard |
| (tie) Lawrence North |
| (tie) Providence |
| (tie) Columbus North |
2005
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Park Tudor |
| 2 | North Central |
| 3 | (tie) Evansville Memorial |
| 4 | (tie) Center Grove |
| 5 | Culver Academy |
| 6 | Terre Haute North |
| 7 | Zionsville |
| 8 | Brebeuf |
| 9 | Delta |
| 10 | Jasper |
| 11 | Lawrence North |
| 12 | Carmel |
| 13 | Brownsburg |
| 14 | Cathedral |
| 15 | Plymouth |
| 16 | Crown Point |
| 17 | Warsaw |
| 18 | Fort Wayne Canterbury |
| 19 | Silver Creek |
| 20 | Franklin Centra |
2004
| Rank | School |
| 1 | North Central |
| 2 | Carmel |
| 3 | Park Tudor |
| 4 | Center Grove |
| 5 | Homestead |
| 6 | Munster |
| 7 | Delta |
| 8 | Evansville Memorial |
| 9 | Terre Haute North |
| 10 | Warsaw |
| 11 | Jasper |
| 12 | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 13 | Castle |
| 14 | Floyd Central |
| 15 | Silver Creek |
| 16 | Zionsville |
| 17 | Evansville North |
| 18 | Carroll (FW) |
| 19 | Indpls Bishop Chatard |
| 20 | (tie) Columbus North |
| (tie) Vincennes Lincoln |
| (tie) Plymouth |
2003
| Rank | School |
| 1 | Carmel |
| 2 | North Central |
| 3 | Park Tudor |
| 4 | Jasper |
| 5 | Terre Haute North |
| 6 | Zionsville |
| 7 | Homestead |
| 8 | Center Grove |
| 9 | Vincennes Lincoln |
| 10 | Evans. Memorial |
| 11 | Floyd Central |
| 12 | West Lafayette |
| 13 | Muncie Burris |
| 14 | Delta |
| 15 | Silver Creek |
| 16 | Penn |
| 17 | Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 18 | Warsaw |
| 19 | Evans. Central |
| 20 | (tie) Northrop |
| (tie) Columbus North |
| (tie) Lawrence North |
2002
| Rank | School |
| 1 | North Central |
| 2 | Carmel |
| 3 | Jasper |
| 4 | Park Tudor |
| 5 | Vincennes Lincoln |
| 6 | Bloomington South |
| 7 | Floyd Central |
| 8 | Penn |
| 9 | Terre Haute North |
| 10 | Providence |
| 11 | Zionsville |
| 12 | Delta |
| 13 | Jennings county |
| 14 | Homestead |
| 15 | Noblesville |
| 16 | FW Northrop |
| 17 | Lawrence North |
| 18 | Warsaw |
| 19 | Bishop Chatard |
| 20 | (tie) Brebeuf |
| (tie) Evansville North |
| (tie) Munster |
2001
| Rank | School |
| 1 | North Central |
| 2 | Park Tudor |
| 3 | Terre Haute South |
| 4 | Carmel |
| 5 | Jasper |
| 6 | Delta |
| 7 | Anderson Highland |
| 8 | Vincennes Lincoln |
| 9 | Cathedral |
| 10 | S.B.St. Joseph's |
| 11 | Homestead |
| 12 | Noblesville |
| 13 | Evansville Central |
| 14 | Bloomington South |
| 15 | F.W.Concordia |
| 16 | Michigan City |
| 17 | South Bend Clay |
| 18 | Lawrence Central |
| 19 | Merrillville |
| 20 | Jeffersonville |
| 21 | Terre Haute North |
| 22 | Castle |
| 23 | Munster |
| 24 | Lake Central |
| 25 | Alexandria |
| 26 | LaPorte |
| 27 | Penn |
| 28 | Jennings County |
